CDE will be closed on Wednesday, Nov. 11 for the Veterans Day holiday.
Title I, Part A Comparability
Title I, Part A Comparability
The Elementary and Secondary Education Act (ESEA), reauthorized as the Every Student Succeeds Act (ESSA), States that the purpose of Title I, Part A is to “provide all children significant opportunity to receive a fair, equitable, and high-quality education, and to close educational achievement gaps.” Title I, Part A funds are intended to provide additional resources for students from high-poverty neighborhoods who are at risk of not meeting State academic standards, beyond what is provided with State and local funds. Section 1118 of ESSA requires local educational agencies (LEAs) to provide State- and locally-funded services in schools receiving support under Title I, Part A that, taken as a whole, are at least comparable to services provided in schools that do not receive support under Title I, Part A.
Obligation to Demonstrate Comparability
LEAs must submit a demonstration of compliance with the Comparability requirements if the LEA has at least one Title I school, with at least 100 students, in a grade span that has two or more schools.
LEAs are exempt from demonstration of compliance with the Comparability requirements if they:
- Do not accept Title I, Part A funds, or
- Only have one school per grade span
LEAs who are not exempt may exclude any schools that have fewer than 100 students from their Comparability analyses.
In prior years, the Colorado Department of Education (CDE) had exempted districts with fewer than 1,000 students from Comparability analyses. However, based on recent U.S. Department of Education’s (ED) guidance, enrollment of less than 1,000 students does not automatically exempt districts from Comparability analyses.
Annual Requirements
CDE presumes that LEAs are meeting ESSA Comparability requirements if they have provided written assurance in their annual ESEA Consolidated Application that they have established and implemented all of the following:
- An LEA-wide salary schedule, and
- A Policy to ensure equivalence among schools in:
- Teachers, administrators, and other staff.
- Provision of curriculum materials and instructional supplies.
LEAs required to demonstrate Comparability will conduct local analyses prior to or at the beginning of the school year and make any necessary adjustments as early as possible to minimize disruption for students. CDE provides an Excel tool, the Comparability Calculator, to help LEAs perform these analyses based on their specific Title I school configurations. LEAs must maintain annual documentation of Comparability and be prepared to submit Comparability documentation to CDE every two years, if requested.
In order to reduce burden on LEAs, CDE performs Comparability calculations using Student October and HR Snapshot data. HR data includes teacher full-time equivalent (FTE) paid with State or local funds (primarily job class code 201), excluding Federally-funded FTEs. If CDE is able to demonstrate Comparability on behalf of the LEA, the LEA is not required to submit any additional analyses or evidence to CDE. If CDE is not able to demonstrate Comparability on behalf of the LEA, the LEA must provide evidence of Comparability using the Comparability Calculator or provide a Comparability Action Plan detailing steps to achieve compliance.
Methods to Calculate Comparability
Comparability calculations fall into two major categories, depending on the LEA’s Title I school configuration: all schools in the grade-span receive Title I, Part A funds or some schools in the grade span receive Title I, Part A funds.
- Grade Span Versus Districtwide Comparison Alternative Method
- All schools in the grade-span receive Title I, Part A funds.
- Some schools in the grade span accept Title I, Part A funds and others do not.
- High-Low Enrollment or Poverty Alternative Method
- Per-Pupil Allocation Alternative Method
- Salary Equivalence Alternative Method
- Student-Instructional Staff Ratio Alternative Method
Grade Span Versus Districtwide Comparison Alternative Method
All schools in the grade-span receive Title I, Part A funds.
Some schools in the grade span accept Title I, Part A funds and others do not.
High-Low Enrollment or Poverty Alternative Method
Per-Pupil Allocation Alternative Method
Salary Equivalence Alternative Method
Student-Instructional Staff Ratio Alternative Method
Comparability and Supplement, Not Supplant (SNS)
Comparability’s focus is educational materials and resources specifically. Comparability should not be confused with SNS, which ensures that Title I schools receive the funds they would have received if they had not participated in the Title I, Part A program. While Comparability and SNS requirements both examine how the LEA distributes State and local funds/resources to schools, they are separate tests that measure different aspects of the supplemental nature of Title I, Part A funds. As such, demonstration of Comparability may not meet SNS demonstration requirements and vice versa. The following scenarios illustrate how LEAs may satisfy one requirement while violating the other.
Note: Although other ESSA Titles do not have a Comparability provision, Titles II, III, and IV do have SNS provisions. For additional information about SNS, please visit the websites for each of the other Title programs.
Comparability FAQs
Resources
The Office of Program Effectiveness in the Federal Programs & Supports Unit along with the Office of Data Services, host webinars to review the Comparability requirements, discuss data entry into the HR collection, and demonstrate how to use the Comparability Calculator.
-
Comparability Calculator - Excel
-
Comparability Action Plan - SmartSheet
-
Demonstrating Comparability - PowerPoint
For Additional Information Contact:
Tina Negley
Program Effectiveness Supervisor
720-766-2793
negley_t@cde.state.co.us
Evita Byrd
ESEA Title I and IV Specialist
720-347-5667
byrd_e@cde.state.co.us






